Best movie of this year hands down!

Good concept, poorly executed.

Bad Acting and worse Bad Screenplay

While it doesn't offer any answers, it both thrills and makes you think.

As a gay man it's disappointing that so many gay men actually like this dreck. Or that it found its way to Tribeca.Every conceivable bad thought anyone ever had about gay men is ruthlessly portrayed here. Oh yes, there's a laugh or two. But mostly it's just awful gross out material that won't give you a break to breath. It's all here. Scat. Vomit discharged onto a guys crack. Sex, sex and more sex. Plenty of frontal. (It's not Dante's Cove which is worse.) There's even a Seth Rogen nude look alike for the chubby chaser crowd. Not to mention a gerbil...and on and on and on and on.You seriously may want to consider having a few drinks before you subject yourself to this disaster. And no, there really is no story line at all. Nothing worth mentioning anyway. If you have an IQ in the range of 3-5 you'll probably like this. If I were any of these actors including Michael Carbonaro, I would try to erase this from my resume and my memory.

OK... Leave your joke in the comment box, I'm sure it's hilarious. As for this movie, it WAS hilarious... at first... but it quickly got old. Its about four gay friends, the summer before college, on a mission to get laid. Along the way they meet their fair share of weird characters and it's pretty much the same as 1000 other coming of age teen comedies, except for the gay part... This movie has some really funny parts, especially the interaction with the lesbians, THAT was classic! Unfortunately, they continue focusing on the one subject, and the jokes just stop being funny after about twenty minutes or so. It's a cool idea, it's a gutsy film to make, and I give praise to everyone brave enough to be a part of it. It probably would have been good if it wasn't so narrow-minded.

As some reviewers noted here, this movie is a gay version of American Pie. I therefore propose it to be renamed "American Fudge".The film "Another Teen Movie" was a spoof on most teenage movies, the way they are made and their story lines. I thought this would be parallel--a spoof on most gay movies. But the director's creativity stopped at just rainbow-coloring the American Pie. I'm not going to criticize sex scenes--they are quite adequate for the film's rating. But if you are going to make a movie about gay teens, at least enable it to get a rating for them to see it. I did not like any of the sex scenes that were not funny, nor did I like any kissing etc., but this opinion is biased since I'm straight. I must add I was particularly disgusted by the scene with the old man and the "girly" boy. We hear too many times about this type of homosexual men going for underage boys (sometimes even early teens). They like their boys young and quite often the law is disregarded when no one is watching. I found the scenes with the teacher to be funny, not because of gross stuff that happened there, but because of the situation the character found himself in. To me it looked like rude humor. I also like the helpful daddy with all those butt plugs (he's a wonderful parent, ain't he?!) To sum up, I wouldn't say the movie was awful. I'm a psychologist and I bet there are a lot of men out there with homosexual curiosity who never admit to anyone they have it for various reasons. They might be buying/renting this movie to safely satisfy this curiosity, as it is disguised as a mainstream comedy. So for the right audience, this film is great. It's very gay, it's nude and doesn't stop at cuddling. Does it correctly portray real-life gay relationships and emotional issues? I don't think so. "American Fudge" is a movie, and it's a spoof, not a documentary.

When I first heard about this movie, I thought it was going to be a total mess...but guess what? It's really great! Unlike many gay movies, this one has a story. You can see how the characters change from the beginning to the end. They managed to create funny situations related to gay interest, but, including 4 love stories that will catch your attention during the whole movie. The result is a funny movie, with and interesting story! Of course not everything in life is roses. There was an aspect that I didn't quite like; The environment! The movie was made as if being gay was the nicest and most accepted thing in the world.Friendly Advice: If you liked this one, then you'll love Eating out 1 and 2.