If you don't like this, we can't be friends.

hyped garbage

It's easily one of the freshest, sharpest and most enjoyable films of this year.

This is one of the best movies I’ve seen in a very long time. You have to go and see this on the big screen.

I hate checking the "Contains Spoiler" checkbox. I don't think I reveal anything specific that isn't already well known about a movie this old but checked it just in case.I was in high school when I saw this film. I believe it established early on the style of film making I have appreciated for the rest of my life. I have been trying to find where this love of quiet, minimalistic, but extremely powerful imagery became such a huge part of my cinematic taste. Although the one big movie I compare this too was made before The Black Stallion, I didn't see it until years later. It was The Black Stallion that was the first of it's type to influence me.This may seem a completely bizarre comparison but one of the films that has a compelling similarity is the original "Alien" film. Little or no deep exposition at the start. Limited dialog, or at least only the dialog that would happen naturally in the moments. No flowery, over the top poetic nonsense. Alien also was "two movies" in "one". A calm non threatening setup, leading to intense conflict.I know I know, these two movies seem completely and utterly opposites and not related in any way, but after watching it again today, Alien was the first movie that popped into my head. One of the things I loved about Alien/Black Stallion are the "sound textures". When you have limited dialog the director or possibly the sound designer, tends to include rich and detailed sounds. For example the scene with Brett in Alien, when the water is dripping on his cap. That scene is brilliant and the sound is compelling. The Black Stallion is filled with moments like this.Another movie, maybe a bit more comparable from an emotional aspect would be "The Natural". Much more dialog, but still minimalistic. A bit more "magical", but it had a similar "feel" and impact. It also had a strong "two movies in one" structure but with a shorter "first half". Also the endings of both while not identical, have a similar emotional release.Rarely do I see a movie again after so many years and still feel the same about it. Usually it's the youthful newness of the movie in my minds eye that doesn't last over the years. I saw this movie again for the first time after at least 15-20 years. If anything it was even a stronger and better movie with my older viewpoint. At least it totally held up. Some movies from my youth look like crap on re-watching years later.The horse "actor" was amazing (was it one or more horses? Not going to check. Can't tell anyway). The trainer has to be the best in the business or else that horse was special. The relationship between the child actor and the horse was simply perfect. After research I discovered the actor grew up with horses... what a perfect combination and I don't doubt this contributed to the realistic relationship between the horse and the actor. The relationship was so good you assumed they must have spent a long time together and developed a true connection. In many movies with animal/people relationships, you can see the animals "acting" to off-camera instructions and the relationship feels forced. The Black Stallion was absolutely perfect in that regard. In the first half of the film I was convinced they simply abandoned the boy and horse on an island with some cameras.Many times child actors are... well... often when a child actor is cast in a lead the decisions are very poor. I hate to beat a dead horse, but Star Wars Episode 1 comes to mind as the number 1 in bad child casting. The actor in this film however, was perfect. Sadly the star of The Black Stallion wasn't able to continue his acting career after a bad accident. Maybe "sad" is the wrong description. He may not feel that way.Casting a child in a film like this requires a genuine talent. You get it wrong and the film is a failure of max proportions. Get it perfect and a modest film can become a hit. Imagine this film with a horribly awful bad actor playing Alec. Oh good grief, if that happened the movie would have flopped and been hard to watch.The supporting cast was also perfect. Micky Rooney was amazing. You honestly believed his back story. Alec's mother also was perfect. Of course, she had that reputation as an actor portraying a supportive mother against her better instincts.The "two movies in one" aspect was brilliantly handled. I remember seeing it the first time and the "transition" felt jolting but not in a bad way. My most recent viewing, the transition felt smoother. This is also another cinematic choice that can be very difficult to pull off.Also, many times this type of "extraordinary animal" movie can be completely unrealistic. This film simply nailed it. There really wasn't any aspect of the developing relationship between the boy and the horse that didn't feel like it could have happened that way. My only tiny bit of skepticism would be to question if a truly wild animal is capable of recognizing when someone helps them out of a stressful situation. A minor quibble and I'm probably wrong. I assume taming or breaking a wild horse would be done in a similar way.Anyway... brilliant movie. One of my top 10. Inspirational movie.It's not in my top 10 of "watch over and over" type films. This is an intense watch. You have to WATCH it. It's not an "easy" watch but it is a brilliant experience.

While traveling with his father (Hoyt Axton), young Alec becomes fascinated by a mysterious Arabian stallion who is brought on board and stabled in the ship he is sailing on. When it tragically sinks both he and the horse survive only to be stranded on a desert island.This film is noted for its beautiful cinematography. Indeed, some of the scenes have no words at all and rely on the horse and the island to tell the tale. And whether it is a good tale or not, it is a good-looking one.Unfortunately, I watched it on the DVD from MGM, which only hints at the bright and brilliant colors. My assumption is the new Criterion disc will take the negative and give it the quality it deserves. If so, I would be more than happy to give the picture an extra star.

I read most of the books in the Black Stallion series when I was a young girl of 8 or 9. The story is a great one. An epic tale. This movie captures the spirit of the first book of the series. Visually this movie is stunning. I would definitely recommend it, especially for horse lovers. I may even go back and read the books again. The book goes into a lot more detail than the movie, of course, but the magic of the story comes across beautifully here. The boy who plays the lead should have won awards for doing such a great job throughout the movie in interacting with the horse. It is a shame what happened to the boy actor who played the lead. In real life his career was cut short by tragedy. I love movies about horses and this one is up there on my list.

Beautiful cinematography can't save this film. The rather simplistic story unfolds as a young boy washes up on an island off the North African coast, after the ship on which he and his father were passengers sunk and the boy was thrown into the waves. Miracles abound. To name just one, when the boy wakes up on the beach after his ordeal he finds, right next to him in the shallow water, his pocket knife, blade already open. Highly unlikely, to put it mildly. By spoon-feeding the viewers with easy answers the film underestimates the intelligence of the movie loving public.The characters are poorly develop, even that of the protagonist, young Alec Ramsey, played without distinction by Kelly Reno. Other actors are equally mediocre. The award for best 'actor' goes to the black stallion.A large part of the first half of the film is taken up by vividly colored and picturesque sunsets, with the boy trying to befriend the horse, but after a while it just gets boring. The second half of the film builds up to the horse race, and for a change some real dialogue takes place. The ending is unfortunately rather predictable.Undiscerning young kids may perhaps unconditionally enjoy the film, but many thinking youngsters will find it a bore, not to mention adults.