A lot more amusing than I thought it would be.

A different way of telling a story

The movie's neither hopeful in contrived ways, nor hopeless in different contrived ways. Somehow it manages to be wonderful

The film may be flawed, but its message is not.

"The Silver Whip" was I'm sure, a vehicle for up and coming star Robert Wagner whom 20th Century Fox was grooming for stardom. It co-starred him with two of the studio's top leading men of the day, Dale Robertson and Rory Calhoun.Wagner plays Jess Harker a disgruntled but ambitious stagecoach driver who is not getting his due. He is driving a local run with a mule team. He longs to drive the main line coach. When he threatens to leave for greener pastures, his girl Kathy Riley (Kathleen Crowley) and two-gun shotgun guard Race Crim (Robertson) arrange for him to be transferred to the main line in spite of dispatcher Luke Bowen's (James Millican) apprehensions.The stage is to carry a large gold shipment which outlaw Slater (John Kellogg) overhears in the saloon. He races to the relay station to meet up with his gang and rob the coach. When the stage arrives at the relay station, Race suspects something and tells Jess to move the stage out of harm's way. Jess disobeys and remains. Following a gunfight with the gang, they make off with the loot.When Race's girlfriend Waco (Lola Albright) and Uncle Ben (Bert Mustin) are killed, Rice is filled with rage. He takes off after the outlaws while Jess joins up with Sheriff Tom Davisson's (Calhoun) posse. They catch up with one of the outlaws (Ian MacDonald) and take him prisoner in spite of Race's desire to hang him on the spot. All of the other bandits were killed by Race except for Slater.Later, when Slater is captured, the townsmen form a lynch mob and convince Race to join them. Jess, meanwhile has hired on as Davisson's deputy and is left in charge of the prisoners. The mob storms the jail and..............................................................................The film was not one of the studio's big budget films of the year. It was filmed in glorious black & white just as the wide screen CinemaScope process was coming in. Robertson is quite good as he goes from confident law abiding to hate filled vigilante. Calhoun has little to do and Wagner does OK as the young Jess. Watch for sagebrush veterans George Chesboro, John Doucette and Edmund Cobb as members of the lynch mob.

Character-driven western whose guiding idea unfortunately is better than the result. Sheriff Tom, tough guy Race, and young man Jess, are friends in a small frontier town. Jess, however, wants a chance to prove himself a man, so he gets trial run as a stage driver. Trouble is he screws up by not driving off to protect doomed passengers when stage is ambushed at a way station. Instead he stays behind to help his friend Race. Now Jess needs to redeem himself by helping Sheriff Tom and posse track down stage robbers before vengeful Race guns them all down. Climax occurs in town when lynch mob gathers to head for Tom's jail.It's really Wagner's film. As the untried Jess, he shows his acting chops in a vivid performance still early in his lengthy career. Robertson (Race) and Calhoun (Tom) also get a lot of screen time as self-assured westerners. Oddly, they look so much alike, I got confused at times. The oater's unusual since no bad guy gets focal time, while the girls are strictly peripheral. Instead, the highlight is a well-photographed and lengthy chase scene across scenic rocks and hills. There's one unexpectedly jarring occurrence that I guess Hollywood convention couldn't let stand without smoothing out. Had they instead let it go extreme, the movie would be memorable. One key point, I wish Robertson's ambiguous character (Race) were more intense. That would have injected needed emotion to the movie as a whole There's a dramatic potential in the key conflict between Race and Tom that's unfortunately underplayed.All in all, it's an interesting western with an unusual plot and some riveting scenery, but drains too much story potential.

Harmon Jones' "The Silver Whip" is apt to be forgotten these days, but this horse opera is pretty good. The cast is a stellar one with Rory Calhoun as the stalwart sheriff, Dale Robertson as the vengeance driven stagecoach guard, and Robert Wagner as a young man learning the ropes of responsibility. Apart from its black & white cinematography, this Twentieth Century Fox western foreshadowed one of the studio's best westerns "Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid" when an outlaw with no place to run leaps off high rocks to plunge into a lake below. "Shane" novelist Jack Schaefer wrote the source novel "First Blood" that this above-average western was adapted from by "North West Mounted Police" scenarist Jesse L. Lasky Jr. penned. The casting of Robertson as the villain distinguishes this otherwise minor western. The last quarter hour of the action foreshadowed the John Wayne movie "Rio Bravo." "You sure never know what a kid's got inside of him," the manager of the stagecoach station observes after the Wagner hero proves his ability to follow orders and live up to his responsibility. Harmon Jones never lets the action slacken in this concise 73-minute western. Good dialogue.

Three of the stars became major television stars as well. And Rory Calhoun, Dale Robertson, and Robert Wagner made an excellent trio.Accompanied by two of the loveliest ladies, Lola Albright and Kathleen Crowley, as well as by some un-credited high-caliber performers such as the great John Doucette, George Cheesbro, and Edmund Cobb, they give us a tense western drama.Anger and revenge for cold-blooded killing always make for drama, and usually the audience, the viewers know which side to take. Here, though, there becomes a question of the right and wrong of lynch law. Who will defend the "official" law, and who will support the old "eye for an eye" law?The denouement is not what we expect.Until then, we are torn, because all the protagonists are good people and it is hard to decide for whom to root.Un-billed is Chuck Connors, but billed is the superb James Millican, as is J.M. Kerrigan in an undemanding but literate and important role."The Silver Whip" is available at YouTube and I highly recommend it.