ridiculous rating

A Disappointing Continuation

This is a small, humorous movie in some ways, but it has a huge heart. What a nice experience.

There is, somehow, an interesting story here, as well as some good acting. There are also some good scenes

It's so beautiful. The location is amazing, makes me wanna go there so much. If anyone knows where the island is, please let me know. What I got frustrated was why was she hallucinating. I wished it was real. Oh well...

It is controversial how to achieve balance between talent and life. Being devoted and excel in one field happens mostly on the account of life and family. But it's all about perspective, of which lens we see the world. For the talent, the world becomes so beautiful in their mind despite all life challenges. The only thing that makes their life complete is acceptance and appreciation by people, rather than being judged by shallow-minded personalities who cannot see other than themselves. It is undeniable that I was touched by the story. For those who watched "Bi Küçük Eylül Meselesi'", I recommend to spare some time and watch Enid (2009), a very successful story writer and teller to children. It's a pity that family and friends in both movies had to suffer rather than live blessed with talent.

On one movie site part of the plot summary reads.. "A weird looking, grubby recluse, comes up-to him and proclaims: "Don't you remember me? I'm the man you fell in love with." This description is as convoluted and confusing as watching this movie. You can call Engin Aky a bunch of things, but in this movie, not many would be agreeing with 'weird and/ or grubby.. and Farah Zeynep Abdullah is most definitely a 'her.' The film has some charm.. but the storyline is way too muddled, it's near impossible to kept track what's going on at any one moment from the next. And really the story is so simple, when you come right down to it, it could have presented in an hour TV show..and with commercials the 45 minutes would've been more than enough.

Basically a variation on the Beauty and the Beast story, Kerem Deren's film focuses on the experiences of young İstanbullu Eylül (Farah Zeynep Abdullah), who has a near-fatal accident resulting in the loss of her short-term memory. To help recover it, her friend Berrak (Ceren Moray) takes her back to the island of Bozcaada, where she went for a location-trip, and encountered Tekin (or Tek) (Engin Akürek), an artist with acute agoraphobia. He has forsaken the sophisticated world of İstanbul for an edenic existence in a seaside home, with no one but match-making child Gülşen (Serra Keskin) for company. Eylül finds his existence rather rustic but strangely attractive, a welcome alternative to the hurlyburly of contemporary İstanbul The film juxtaposes Eylül's currently confused state of mind with an analysis of what happened to her in the past; she had a love-affair with Tekin, which became passionate on both sides. Despite the ordinariness of his life, she fell for him; but left him in the belief that she had to return to her metropolitan İstanbul life. Her accident - and subsequent memory-loss - was caused by reading something in the paper about Tekin's fate. The film creates an idyllic world on Bozcaada full of sunshine, quaint buildings and unpopulated cafés; the place where any harassed city-dweller might like to escape to. It is Eylül's misfortune that she does not understand the advantages of this life, or Tekin's true feelings for her. There are a few clichéd moments, especially involving the two lovers on the beach; and Abdullah is at times extremely unconvincing in her role, especially when it comes to communicating her disordered state of mind. Nonetheless BI KÜÇÜK EYLÜL MESELESİ is entertaining to watch.