hyped garbage

Good idea lost in the noise

I was totally surprised at how great this film.You could feel your paranoia rise as the film went on and as you gradually learned the details of the real situation.

It's funny, it's tense, it features two great performances from two actors and the director expertly creates a web of odd tension where you actually don't know what is happening for the majority of the run time.

"The Execution of Wanda Jean" is a documentary from HBO films that tries to question the appropriateness of the execution of Wanda, an explosive woman who was described as being on the borderline between mental retardation (though through the course of the interviews, she did not appear to be obviously mentally retarded and a follow-up IQ test had a higher score--still well below normal). They began working on this film before her eventual execution and features not only interviews with her but her family, friends, folks from the criminal justice system and the victim's family. As far as the murder goes, Wanda Jean's lover, Gloria, was trying to leave her and even went to the police for help. But Gloria gunned her down in the parking lot of the police station in a moment of rage.While this is a reasonably well made film and makes a decent point about the appropriateness of the death penalty in this specific case, the film does have one HUGE problem...this was NOT a one-time incident. The fact that Wanda Jean had previously murdered another person when she got angry makes this a difficult case to get behind and champion. On the other hand, the recent Oscar-nominated short documentary, "Last Day of Freedom" makes a much better case, as the guy in question had never murdered anyone before and suffered not only from a cognitive impairment but PTSD and, perhaps, schizophrenia. This case was clear....by almost anyone's standards, he should not have been executed. As for Wanda Jean, she did not appear too slow to understand her actions and it makes the film a much more difficult appeal for the repeal of the death penalty. It's a muddier case...but one where I found myself feeling very, very little sympathy for Wanda Jean--especially with so much money and effort being spent on her defense. And, sadly, I think the filmmakers also seemed to feel very little for the many victims Wanda Jean created. An even stronger emphasis on the family and her dead lover would have served the film better.Well made but a bit unsettling due to its choice of prisoners. I really doubt if this film will change many minds. Would justice have been better served if she had just spent the remainder of her life in prison, probably. But she was a very dangerous woman...and one who hurt so many people. And I also felt showing close-ups of her in the coffin at her funeral seemed a bit gratuitous.After the movie was over, I was left with the thought that it's amazing that so many folks worked so hard to help Wanda Jean AFTER she was a lost cause (i.e., had two murders behind her). What if these folks had worked with Wanda Jean or people like her BEFORE they got to that point? To me, this all seems a bit misguided.

I was watching her story on A&E today and I found it very interesting. so interesting that I immediately Googled her name so that I could read about her story in more depth. What I did not know was that she was convicted previously and did crime for killing another lover. I was feeling sorry for her until I read more about her and I see why she was not granted clemency. It seems that she was making a habit out of killing and she needed to be stopped. LIke her family, I think that execution was a cop out and she should have spent the rest of her life in prison. Her team worked exceptionally hard on her case and at the end was really emotional and I could see the sincerity of his pleas for her to live. Excellent piece of work and A&E should re-play it.

I am sure the family knew why their loved one was in prison. They were asking why is she being executed.If that was your mother, sister, daughter, granddaughter would you feel the same about the death penalty? Killing people who kill people to show that killing people is 100% wrong. It costs more to execute a person then to keep them in prison the rest of their life.It is interesting you think they don't suffer when a person is put to death. Maybe you should tell the states who have put executions on hold right now that they don't suffer.There is pain from both families. In a matter of seconds lives can be turned upside down forever. The death penalty does not stop that. «An execution is not simply death. It is just as different from the privation of life as a concentration camp is from prison. It adds to death a rule, a public premeditation known to the future victim, an organization which is itself a source of moral sufferings more terrible than death. Capital punishment is the most premeditated of murders, to which no criminal's deed, however calculated can be compared. For there to be an equivalency, the death penalty would have to punish a criminal who had warned his victim of the date at which he would inflict a horrible death on him and who, from that moment onward, had confined him at his mercy for months. Such a monster is not encountered in private life.» copied «The lethal injection method … has turned dying into a still life, thereby enabling the state to kill without anyone involved feeling anything. Any remaining glimmers of doubt – about whether the man received due process, about his guilt, about our right to take life – cause us to rationalize these deaths with such catchwords as "heinous," "deserved," "deterrent," "justice," and "painless." We have perfected the art of institutional killing to the degree that it has deadened our natural, quintessentially human response to death.» -- Susan Blaustein, journalist, reacting to having witnessed an execution in Texas, in: "Witness to Another Execution", Harpers Magazine, May 1994, p. 53.

I just saw the HBO Documentary on the Execution of Wanda Jean Allen. I found it very compelling. It raised serious questions about mental state and education, or the lack there of. I have long wondered about the families who have to go through watching their loved ones fight for a stay of execution, however, I found that this particular family seemed to forget what got Wanda Jean on the Death Row. There were many family members who kept asking "Why is this happening to her?" or "Why are they putting her (or us) through this?" The answer is very simple: Wanda Jean killed Gloria Leathers! I'm not saying that they shouldn't join in the fight to save Wanda Jean's life, but let's not forget that she did the crime! Also, if you are going to fight for something, don't fight with those who are trying to help you. There were times when I felt the family worked against the lawyer that was trying to help Wanda Jean.With that said, I couldn't stop watching the documentary and would recommend it to others.