Who payed the critics

It really made me laugh, but for some moments I was tearing up because I could relate so much.

A great movie, one of the best of this year. There was a bit of confusion at one point in the plot, but nothing serious.

The movie really just wants to entertain people.

"And now, for a man who needs no introduction – Seymour Bernstein!" While such a statement may be appropriate in some circles, if it were universally true, there might not be a need for the documentary "Seymour: An Introduction" (PG, 1:24). Seymour Bernstein, among fans of classical music, is a well-known New York concert pianist and music teacher. Viewers of this film will get to know him as such and will want to add to that resume "wise man and all-around good guy". Actor Ethan Hawke seems to think so. He was so impressed by meeting Bernstein that he decided to make a documentary about his life. The resulting film was seen on the festival circuit in the U.S. and Canada during the late summer and fall of 2014, received a limited theatrical release in those two countries in March 2015 and appeared at international film festivals throughout the spring of 2015. And if film festival love weren't enough, as of the writing of this review, on the Rotten Tomatoes website, this movie has an 88% rating from audiences and a 100% critics rating! When have 100% of film critics agreed on anything? I try not to be swayed by critics or popular opinion when I write my reviews, so I am now prepared to make my assessment as to whether I agree with the nearly universal acclaim this documentary has received.Seymour Bernstein demonstrated extraordinary talent on the piano as a teenager, grew up to become a world-renown concert pianist and composer, but then suddenly gave up performing at the age of 50 to focus on music education. Bernstein has had remarkable success in many aspects of music and his life is a very interesting story waiting to be discovered. But this documentary doesn't stop there. It reveals Seymour Bernstein as a remarkable person. He has a tremendous passion for classical music and has learned and taught much along those lines, but it's how his love of music has informed his life that is most compelling to those of us who know more about Post-It notes than musical notes.In directing this film, Hawke never gets flashy with his cinematic portrait of Seymour Bernstein, but uses a variety of effective methods to introduce us to the man and his music. We see archival footage of piano concerts and more recent footage of the master teaching his students. As we watch the latter, we are struck by the instructor's perfectly balanced approach – a dogged pursuit of perfection sometimes nearly overshadowed by his generous and encouraging nature. We also learn who Bernstein is as a man and a musician through interviews with his current and former students and conversations with the man himself, as he tells his story and reveals what he learned about life along the way. To illustrate this last point, it may be easiest to give you a sample of Bernstein's pearls of wisdom, in his own words: "The true essence of who we are resides in our talent – whatever talent we have." "The people who don't want me to succeed for their own selfish reasons can't touch me." "The most important thing that music teachers can do for their pupils is to inspire an emotional reaction, not just for the music, but more importantly, for life." "We sense in music a reflection of ourselves, a reminder of our own potential for perfection." "I never dreamt that with my own two hands, I could touch the sky." There's plenty more where that came from, but beyond telling Bernstein's story and encouraging him to reflect back on his 88 years, there's a bit of a real-time drama going on in this movie as well. In the midst of the interviews and the background footage, as the documentary is being filmed, Bernstein is preparing to perform his first public concert in many years. We see him choose his piano like a master chef selects just the right spice and uses just the right amount. Bernstein has the refined ear of a man who has been doing this for decades, but the boyish enthusiasm of someone sitting behind the keys for the first time. As he plays the piano he selected just for this occasion at New York's Steinway Hall Rotunda for an audience consisting of Hawke's theater group, the moment elicits an emotional reaction in Bernstein. The music still touches him, much as his story and his generous and wise spirit touch us."Seymour: An Introduction" is the rare completely non-controversial, heart-felt documentary that you can just sit back and enjoy, but it could have been a little sharper than it was. The bare-bones style of telling its story was generally appropriate for the film, but it wouldn't have distracted from its subject to be just a little more creative in its presentation. In addition, some of the camera work and some of the editing choices came across as slightly amateurish. This documentary isn't as close to perfect as the music that Bernstein plays, but definitely has the power to elicit an emotional reaction of its own. I'm giving this one a "B+". That qualifies as a general recommendation from me and is positive enough to group me together with all those professional critics who favorably reviewed this movie. Count me in, ladies and gentlemen. Seymour Bernstein is a man well worth meeting and I'm glad Ethan Hawke made the introduction.

As a musician of 50 years standing and an international teaching and performing career, I can honestly say, this movie was a "stunner". Professor Bernstein embodies all of those qualities of a teacher, a performer and a wise professor of life and culture that we all emulate and have tried in our careers to articulate. He is more than a "guru" but an icon of performance practice and pedagogy that will stand the test of time in this important and beautiful film.Ethan Hawke should be commended and lauded for bringing this important man and his wisdom to light in this profound way. In my opinion, this film should be "required viewing" for every pedagogue, music lover, and aspiring performer. It should (at least) be in the library of every university, music school and college in the country. Fantastic film and the best music film I have ever seen.

. . . I drove way out to view SEYMOUR: AN INTRODUCTION. It turns out that director Ethan Hawke's film doesn't even mention the Glass Family (or even BOYHOOD's Evans clan). SEYMOUR actually is about a father who had "three daughters and a pianist." After this ivory tickler saw body bags when drafted into the U.S. Army fighting in Korea, he cut short his concert career to become a piano teacher (like Marion the Librarian in THE MUSIC MAN). This title character, Seymour Bernstein, apparently lacked the stomach to tackle the showier popular pieces a concert career demands, such as Rachmaninoff's Third, which was pulled off by the mental guy in SHINE. Disparaging successful, crowd-pleasing pianists here such as Glenn Gould, Liberace, and Billy Joel, Mr. Bernstein spends his post-concert hall years in his one-room apartment composing pieces with titles like "Belinda the Chipmunk" and pounding out tunes written by unbalanced minds, such as that 25-year-old guy who married a Sweet Sixteen gal, Schumann. They say "Those who can, do." Others teach.

.....about a man who made it his life mission to feed others' souls through the study of music of great emotional richness, intellectual depth and beauty. A must see and a wonderful reprieve from the shallow, titillating stuff we are continually inundated by. Subtle camera angles, expert scene selections and gorgeous musical choices create a tempo to this movie that engages the watcher without doing all the work for him. Kudos to Ethan Hawke for recognizing the substance, wisdom and humanity of Seymour, for resisting the temptation to insert his ego into the story, and for allowing conversations that require the audience members (whether they play the piano or not) to exercise their minds, to think, consider, wonder, reflect about their own lives and passions. You may find yourself, like me, wanting to hear those kernels of wisdom and truth again and again, to deepen your understanding and glean more fully their meaning, and to be moved once more by Seymour's magical, beautiful artistry.