Really Surprised!

Beautiful, moving film.

The movie's neither hopeful in contrived ways, nor hopeless in different contrived ways. Somehow it manages to be wonderful

The film may be flawed, but its message is not.

Don Knotts gets one of his most beloved film vehicles here with this amiable remake of the Bob Hope comedy "The Paleface". That master of nervous energy plays Jesse W. Heywood, a Philadelphia dentist in the 19th century who decides that he wants to ply his trade in the Old West. Instead, he gets mixed up with a former outlaw turned government agent (striking, fiery redhead Barbara Rhoades), whose mission is to expose the men selling rifles to the Comanches."The Shakiest Gun in the West" is a cute, if not uproarious, Western comedy. It has enough laughs, production values, and spirited performances to make it a good time. The gags (some of them recycled from "The Paleface") were never quite inspired for this viewer, but they were still worthy of some chuckles. Certainly Knotts is perfectly cast as this tenderfoot who is led to believe that he's handier in a scrap than he really is. Roles like this were his stock in trade for years. Sexy Rhoades is a very fine leading lady, and the supporting cast features a reasonable amount of familiar faces: Jackie Coogan, Don 'Red' Barry, Ruth McDevitt, Frank McGrath, Terry Wilson, Carl Ballantine, Pat "Mr. Miyagi" Morita, Dub Taylor, Dick Wilson, etc.Vic Mizzy, the regular composer for these Universal / Don Knotts comedies, comes up with appropriately goofy music, and a talented crew create a great, classic Western look for the various wacky goings-on.Good fun for Don Knotts fans.Seven out of 10.

There's nothing wrong with the premise of this movie. In fact, the premise is really quite amusing. Jesse Heywood (played by Don Knotts) is a newly graduated bumbling dentist who moves out to the Old West to practice and bumbles his way into being mistaken for a big-time gunfighter. It's quite silly in a fun kind of way. It doesn't have very many uproarious laughs but it keeps you smiling. To me, though, it doesn't have enough substance to be a big screen movie. Don Knotts played the part of Heywood well - he played it basically as Don Knotts would play any part. I like Don Knotts, but really - he's a second banana type who's made for TV. As second banana to Andy Griffith in "The Andy Griffith Show" or to John Ritter in "Three's Company" he added a lot with his own unique comedic style. As leading man in a Hollywood movie (even a silly one like this) he just doesn't have the presence to carry it.This is a bit slow to get started, and in all honesty Knotts struck me as a bit old to be just graduating as a dentist (although that might have been appropriate to the character - Heywood had spent his whole life in his mother's pocket, so to speak, and now was finally branching out on his own against her will.) Once Barbara Rhoades entered the scene as the beautiful stagecoach robber turned government agent it picks up steam a bit, although she also has little screen presence and has been consistently a supporting actress at best, mostly on TV. There's nothing especially wrong with this. I just found that it had trouble filling 100 minutes of screen time.

I know it's a remake of Paleface, which I also enjoyed, but I liked "Shakiest.." better. It was...dare I say it?...cute. Don Knotts' patented nervous Nelly riff was great. Nobody does it better than he did. Barbara Rhodes was beautiful, sexy, and fiery, much more so than Jane Russell. This is no slam against Ms. Russell. Ms. Russell had a smoldering sensuality few actresses even today could match. And I loved the subtle gender role reversal at the end. Few actors other than Don Knotts could have pulled it off without seeming weird or gay. Not that there is anything wrong with being gay, mind you! I am just saying is all.

I love this movie. It is hilarious. Don Knotts proves once again why he was so beloved by audiences, especially children. His winning, comedic character is so sweetly vulnerable. He is a great example to today's comedians, who rely on vulgarities and smart-Alec comments to "entertain" audiences. There are many wonderful supporting players on hand, such as Carl Ballantine, Pat Morita and Donald "Red" Barry. And of course the lovely Barbara Rhoades. Seeing this film as a little boy in the theatre, I thought there was no lovelier creature on the planet-- especially in that green velvet dress!I hope this commentary is more helpful than the inane, pseudo-intellectual ramblings of the previous comment, which, if it was not made in jest, should have been-- there is no other excuse for it. At least we both agree-- this is a terrific film!