Overrated

Admirable film.

The performances transcend the film's tropes, grounding it in characters that feel more complete than this subgenre often produces.

One of the worst ways to make a cult movie is to set out to make a cult movie.

Jay Singh (Riz Ahmed) is a westernized Indian. He and his friends travel out into rural Rajasthan and stays at a local hotel. He is taken with villager Trishna (Freida Pinto) performing at the hotel. She and her father are injured in a car accident. Her father can't work and they struggle with the debt. Jay offers her a job at his family's hotel outside of Jaipur. Jay falls deeper in love and one night, he does something which changes everything.Director Michael Winterbottom brings out a beauty from the setting and Freida Pinto is a large part of that. The story lacks a focus that would raise its inherit social commentary and tension. First I would make Jay's hotel much more modern. It needs to differentiate from Trishna's home town. Then there is that night. It's filmed with so much ambiguity that it doesn't really make the point hard enough. This is an adaptation of the classic Tess of the D'Urbervilles, and there is a good parallel between the two social worlds. This movie should work a lot better than this.

Set in contemporary Mumbai, TRISHNA is the tragic tale of a young woman (Freida Pinto) plucked from a village by a rich entrepreneur (Riz Ahmed) to live the high life, but finds herself very much at his beck and call with very little opportunity for self-determination. The story is an object lesson in how to understand the phrase "all that glisters is not gold," while pointing out the evils of capitalism in the newly-rich world of the Indian bourgeoisie.Michael Winterbottom's film has a fine sense of place, stressing the contrasts between the young woman Trishna's rural origins, her new life in Mumbai and her subsequent decampment to Rajasthan, where she is expected to work as a servant to Jay - the entrepreneur - while being a lover at the same time. The combination of roles proves too much for her, leading to a violent denouement. Jay is portrayed as a superficial character for whom money has far more importance than love; on many occasions the two concepts are deliberately conflated so that he can achieve his ends. Riz Ahmed turns in a fine performance, his facial expressions seldom changing as he returns to India from a prosperous life in London and expects the local people to act at his beck and call.Stylistically speaking, however, TRISHNA is rather irritating. Winterbottom's camera finds it difficult to focus on one particular object or person at a time; the shooting style is jerky, with several fast cuts between one thing and another. This serves a thematic purpose - to underline the superficialities of Jay's existence - but becomes rather difficult to watch. Consequently we find it difficult to sympathize with the protagonists - especially Trishna, even though she is very much the victim of a patriarchal society. Freida Pinto turns in a nuanced performance, but Winterbottom does not allow us to focus much on her facial expressions. The film might have worked better as a tragic love story if he had permitted us to understand her complex state of mind more fully.

Trishna is a love story based on the Thomas Hardy novel Tess of the D'urbervilles. I haven't read it or seen the Polanski adaptation with Nastassia Kinski. Freida Pinto is the Tess character this time round, and she is breathtakingly beautiful; so casting is not the problem here. The story is so fractured, and the editing so poor, that I don't know what the filmmakers were going for.It begins with a group of bored upper class Indians on a balcony discussing the best cities to party in. They get in a Jeep and drive recklessly around like a bunch of college frat boys. They visit an ancient temple where Jay; the leader of the pack, spots the stunning Trishna. He gets up to dance with her and later drops her off at the lower class families home. The next day, Trishna is riding on the back of her father's truck to deliver produce when they crash into another vehicle and her dad is so badly injured that he cannot work. Jay comes to the rescue by offering Trishna a job at his father's big resort hotel. She works as a servant and he eventually has an encounter with her. The next morning she goes back home very quietly. Three months of vomiting and a visit to a doctor confirm a pregnancy which is terminated. Jay reappears, and a few dance numbers are presented in between for no apparent reason. Trishna ends up at another of Jay's dad's hotels working once again as a servant. They also have a secret sexual relationship which grows cold and distant very quickly. At this point, I had lost interest in both Jay and Trishna. The camera loves Ms. Pinto, but she needs better material to work with.

Tess of The D'Urbervilles is a brilliant novel, with a wealth of material for any director to get their teeth into. Setting the story in modern-day India was a really good idea- when Michael Winterbottom put his twist on scenes from the novel, they worked well and gave an insight into what the film could have been.The confusing and frustrating element of this film for anybody who's read the novel is that at the heart of the book is a brilliant love triangle. Tess is caught in the clutches of callous playboy Alec D'Urberville but hopes to find salvation in her new lover, the godlike Angel Clare- however, both men fail her. For some inexplicable reason, Winterbottom chooses to merge Angel and Alec together, into the character of Jay, a British-Indian, so we have a good guy who inexplicably turns bad. Even a good actor would struggle to pull this off but Riz Ahmed, who has to be one of the worst actors I've ever seen, fails completely. Winterbottom seems to have asked him to improvise parts in order to create a naturalistic feel. Yes, they tried to do Tess Of The D'Urbervilles, a tragedy in the Greek style or at the very least a nineteenth century melodrama, in a realistic style. What are we going to have next, naturalistic Hamlet? "Yeah, Hamlet, I'm sorry about murdering your father but I really fancied your mother. You know how it is." I'm not familiar with Winterbottom's work but I vaguely recalled that it was a bit pornographic. An hour or so into the film, I was wondering when the smut would come. And then I saw Jay flicking through a copy of-you guessed it, the Karma Sutra. At this point, a couple actually walked out of the cinema, and the remaining audience were either shocked, amused, horrified or a mixture of all three. Trishna's descent into sex object is upsetting but it is so predictably done that the tragedy is lost.As for the leading lady, Frieda Pinto is very good as the passive heroine. As Roman Polanski did in the 1978 adaptation of the novel, Winterbottom lingers on Pinto's beauty, and the beauty and vibrancy of India. There is perhaps a little too much lingering- there is not much dialogue, and when there is dialogue, it is banal.It's interesting to see what they did with the story and Pinto is very watchable but this is very much a wasted opportunity. It is pretty hard to make Tess lacklustre, but Winterbottom has managed it. The fact that he's done two other films based on Thomas Hardy novels is worrying.