Death and the Maiden
A political activist is convinced that her guest is a man who once tortured her for the government.
-
- Cast:
- Sigourney Weaver , Ben Kingsley , Stuart Wilson , Karen Strassman
Similar titles
Reviews
Redundant and unnecessary.
Don't listen to the Hype. It's awful
It is not deep, but it is fun to watch. It does have a bit more of an edge to it than other similar films.
what a terribly boring film. I'm sorry but this is absolutely not deserving of best picture and will be forgotten quickly. Entertaining and engaging cinema? No. Nothing performances with flat faces and mistaking silence for subtlety.
Roman Polanski does something that is not easy here: he transfers a play to the screen, and never lets you forget that it is a play you're watching, but he makes it completely cinematic at the same time. The play itself is a great enigma about truth, doubt, vigilantism and justice. I don't want to give away the ending, but it is masterfully designed and executed. It's an intense and compelling film, the kind that invites long debates after it's over. The three leads are perfectly cast: Weaver and Kingsley are at the peak of their powers, but Wilson is much more than just "a third wheel". *** out of 4.
Paulina Escobar (Sigourney Weaver) and her lawyer husband Gerardo (Stuart Wilson) live in a remote home in a South American country still dealing with its recent dictatorship. Paulina is on edge haunted by the torture she suffered. One stormy night, Gerardo gets a ride home with neighbor Dr. Roberto Miranda (Ben Kingsley). Paulina recognizes his voice as that of her unseen tormentor and she takes him prisoner. Gerardo tries desperately to talk her out of the situation and agrees to be the man's defense lawyer as she tries him in her trial.It's a three-person play and everybody delivers. Weaver is amazing and Wilson is great. There are simply no words to describe Kingsley. Director Roman Polanski keeps the static location compelling and really relies on the actors to develop the climbing tension.
"Death and the Maiden" tells a harrowing story, one that's not meant to be pleasant. But even so, there is a difference between telling an unpleasant story and creating an unpleasant experience, and unfortunately, director Roman Polanski doesn't maintain that distinction with this film.He's proved that he knows how in other films, like "Rosemary's Baby" and "Repulsion," neither of which dwell on pleasant themes but both of which are exhilaratingly entertaining. "Death and the Maiden" is an oppressive slog, a film that must be endured rather than enjoyed. Sigourney Weaver and Ben Kingsley give top-notch performances, but the whole thing is too one note and aggressively depressing to be very good.Grade: C
Considering that this is a play and rather looks like one, it's pretty good. Well, it's good anyway.A lawyer, Gerardo (Stuart Wilson) and his wife Paulina (Sigourney Weaver) have just retired in their comfortable, isolated house next to a cliff overhanging the sea. The location is somewhere in South America, in a country that has just emerged from despotism and become a democracy. A car has trouble on the road in front of their house. Dr. Miranda (Ben Kingsley) rouses them and asks for help, but an electrical storm has knocked out both the power and the phone.Gerardo and Dr. Miranda are chatting in the living room while Paulina is still in bed. Hearing Miranda's voice, she sits up in alarm, sneaks outside, burns off in Miranda's car and pushes it over a cliff.That, I guess, is the end of Act I. Most of the time we spend with Gerardo and Miranda in the living room. The two men are at loose ends and drink themselves into a cheerfully befuddled state. I can't remember many drunk scenes better than this one. Kingsley, in particular, is given marvelous lines and delivers them as if they were gifts to the audience -- cynical, ironic, high brow, amiable. "I would like to quote Nietzsche in a situation like this," says Kingsley. "At least I think it was Nietzsche. Maybe it was Freud." Gerardo, "If you can remember a quotation, it's usually Freud." The dialog is delicious and matter of fact. The two men are sitting on the porch steps, still thinking Paulina is asleep, musing about where a thief might have driven Miranda's car, and why. "I'm an idiot," says Kingsley. "I'm running down the road yelling 'That's my car!' Of course the thief knows that. That's the whole POINT." Later, when they find out that Paulina has stolen the car, "I mean, what is this -- a regular thing or what? How long do you think we might have to wait? A day or two? A month?" Then the humor dwindles to a palpitating point and vanishes, and the movie becomes echt-serious. Paulina claims that Miranda worked as an interrogator for the now-deposed dictatorship and that he beat, tortured, and raped the women who were his prisoners -- Paulina included. (She's explicit about the techniques.) Gerardo thinks she's crazy. Miranda is astonished and scared to death.Paulina has Miranda tied up and puts him on trial, appointing Gerardo his defense counsel. Some "trial"! If Miranda confesses and shows genuine contrition she'll let him go, otherwise she'll shoot him through the head. Miranda, sensibly, is perfectly willing to confess and get out of this mad house but, since he claims to have had nothing to do with the previous regime, he doesn't know what to confess to. Paulina wants details -- what was she tied up with, ropes or wires? -- that Miranda says he is unable to provide.It's a harrowing movie, with occasional arcs of electricity jumping through it. I'm not certain the ending is played exactly as it would be in real life, but it hardly matters because the acting on the part of all three principals is unimpeachable.I don't want to give away the climax but I'll sum up my impression by saying that it's quite possible to be guilty OR innocent, while still being mad.See it if you can. It's a hard film to forget.